Well-Rounded and Grounded: What Colleges Are Really Looking For
How does your student stack up?
College admissions officers aren’t searching for “perfect” students. They’re looking for well-rounded, grounded young adults—students who have challenged themselves, followed their interests with intention, and shown they’re ready to contribute on campus.
A survey conducted by Money.com highlights the attributes colleges consistently value when building an incoming class. As you read through the list, think less about checking boxes and more about the story your student’s application tells.
Key Traits That Support College Admissions Success
A rigorous high school curriculum
Students who take challenging coursework—such as AP, IB, or honors classes—demonstrate academic readiness and a willingness to stretch themselves.
Strong grades with positive momentum
Admissions teams like to see sustained effort and, ideally, an upward trend. In fact, slightly lower grades in a rigorous program are often preferred over straight A’s in less demanding classes.
Standardized test scores that align with performance
ACT or SAT scores should generally be consistent with a student’s classroom achievement. While testing policies vary, scores still provide helpful context when submitted.
A thoughtful, personal application essay
The essay is where students come to life. Colleges value writing that offers insight into a student’s personality, values, and goals—authentic, reflective, and clearly written.
Meaningful involvement in a few activities
Depth matters more than breadth. Passionate commitment to a small number of in- or out-of-school activities carries far more weight than light participation in many.
Demonstrated leadership and initiative
Students who step up—starting a club, leading a team, organizing an effort—show they’re prepared to contribute and lead on campus.
Personal qualities that enrich the campus community
Colleges intentionally build diverse classes, seeking students from different backgrounds, perspectives, regions, and life experiences.
Intellectual curiosity
Whether through reading, research, hobbies, or independent exploration, curiosity signals a student who will engage fully in the academic environment.
Genuine interest in the college
Campus visits, interviews (when offered), and thoughtful engagement all demonstrate enthusiasm and help students stand out.
Strong letters of recommendation
Teachers and counselors provide valuable perspective on a student’s character, integrity, work ethic, and love of learning.
Special talents or skills
From athletics to the arts to technical or creative strengths, colleges want to know what a student will bring to campus—and how they’ll grow once they’re there.
Out-of-school experiences
Work, community service, youth organizations, and faith-based involvement all count. Again, commitment and impact matter more than casual participation.
The Big Takeaway
College admissions success isn’t about perfection—it’s about intention, growth, and authenticity. The good news? It’s not too late to make thoughtful adjustments, refine the story, and focus on what truly matters.
With the right guidance and a clear plan, students can present themselves not just as qualified applicants—but as future contributors to a college community.